St Augustine Hotel By At Mine Hospitality in Miami Beach, Florida works if you want a clean, simple South Beach base; skip it if you need quiet, character, or full-service amenities.
How to think about St Augustine Hotel By At Mine Hospitality
• Book this if you want a clean, modern, no-frills room in the heart of South Beach and will spend most of your time out.
• Expect noticeable noise and only basic amenities; this is not a quiet, full-service resort.
• Couples and solo travelers focused on beach and nightlife are the best fit.
• Families, light sleepers, and design seekers should look elsewhere in Miami Beach.
• Treat it as a practical, well kept base camp, not as a destination hotel in its own right.
The good
• Strong South Beach location for walking to the beach, Art Deco district, and nightlife
• Rooms feel modern, uncluttered, and reliably clean across categories
• Staff earn repeated praise for being friendly and helpful
• Room size is generally better than many older South Beach hotels
• Practical touches like desks, WiFi, and fridges work for short work-leisure stays
The bad
• Noise from the street, other guests, and air conditioners is a recurring complaint
• Limited breakfast and minimal common areas make this feel closer to an upgraded motel than a full hotel
• Some room layouts and bathrooms compromise privacy for couples, and even more for families
• Decor is generic and not especially "Miami" or home-like
• Parking is paid, off site, and not frictionless if you are driving
Room reality: space, layout, and what you actually get
Rooms here are modern, simple, and more spacious than the typical tiny South Beach crash pad. Photos match reality: you get a clean bed, neutral decor, and enough floor space to move around without weaving through furniture.
Storage is functional but not generous. You will likely have a small closet or open shelves, fine for a carry-on and a few outfits, less ideal if you arrive with multiple large suitcases or beach gear for a family.
Desks or small work surfaces show up consistently and are properly usable for a laptop session. Lighting is even and practical, with decent natural light in many rooms. Bathrooms follow the same neutral, modern theme, with solid basic fixtures rather than spa-like touches.
The big miss is personality and separation of zones. You should not expect a living area, dining space, or any sense of an apartment-style layout. This is a clean bedroom-and-bath product, not a place to hang out for hours each day.
Noise and environment: who struggles here
Noise is an actual decision point at this property. Reviews repeatedly mention thin walls, hallway and street noise, and air conditioning units that are audible at night.
If you are used to city sounds and plan to lean into the South Beach scene, this will be manageable. If you are a light sleeper, coming with kids, or expecting a calm beach retreat, you will likely be disappointed, even with earplugs.
The combination of South Beach location, older building bones, and modern but not acoustically ambitious renovations explains the pattern. You are near bars, traffic, and late returns, and the insulation is only average. Families and early-to-bed guests feel it the most because their schedule conflicts with the neighborhood rhythm.
Air conditioning noise shows up in multiple reviews, often as a secondary issue that becomes annoying over several nights. For someone staying two or three nights for nightlife or beach days, this is tolerable. For remote workers taking calls from the room or anyone hoping for mid-day naps, it is a bigger problem.
What actually holds up once you are there
What works here
• Consistently clean rooms and bathrooms, with upkeep that matches the photos
• Strong location for walking to the beach, Art Deco sights, and South Beach dining
• Rooms feel decently sized for this part of Miami Beach
• Staff are regularly described as kind, responsive, and helpful
• In-room basics like WiFi, desk, fridge, and AC are reliably present
What does not hold up
• Noise insulation is weaker than marketing or photos might suggest
• Breakfast is limited or absent at times, so you cannot rely on it as a core feature
• Some bathroom designs offer limited privacy, awkward for non-couples sharing a room
• There is no meaningful lobby lounge or social space despite the aparthotel label
• Parking is off site and paid, adding friction for drivers compared with truly on-site options
The positives matter because many South Beach hotels at this price level struggle with cleanliness and worn interiors. Here, housekeeping and maintenance show up strongly in both images and reviews, which is a genuine advantage if you care most about a decent room in a chaotic area.
Complaints cluster around things the property is structurally unlikely to fix: building acoustics, compact public spaces, and the gap between "aparthotel" as a term and the actual absence of kitchenettes or living rooms. Once you recognize you are booking a well located, modern room rather than a lifestyle residence, the experience becomes easier to evaluate.
Amenities and operations: what this place really offers
What you can count on
• Fast, simple walk to the beach and South Beach attractions
• Free WiFi, work desks, AC, and in-room fridges as standard conveniences
• Helpful front desk presence with express check-in and check-out
• EV charging access nearby, useful if you are road-tripping with an electric car
• Luggage storage that makes early arrivals and late departures easier
Where expectations get people
• The "aparthotel" positioning can imply kitchens or in-room cooking, which are not part of the experience
• Breakfast is inconsistent and not a strong point, so plan to get coffee and food nearby
• There is no pool, gym, or true resort-style amenity stack, despite the prime location
• Off-site paid parking adds cost and hassle compared to properties with on-site garages
• Common areas are minimal, so you are mostly living in your room or out in the city
Marketing leans on convenience and South Beach energy, which is accurate, but it does not make clear how lean the amenity set is compared with larger hotels a few blocks away. This is a sleep-and-shower base for people who will spend their time on the beach or out in the city.
If you mentally rank this against full-service resorts or design-forward boutiques, you will over-expect. Compare it instead to other small South Beach hotels that trade big amenities for better pricing and location; in that peer group, its operations look solid.
Who this place actually suits
Works for
• Couples who want a clean, modern room steps from the beach and nightlife
• Solo travelers who value location and cleanliness more than amenities
• Short business or work-leisure stays needing a desk, WiFi, and mainland access
• Travelers planning to spend most waking hours out in Miami Beach rather than in the hotel
Not for
• Light sleepers or anyone who needs a genuinely quiet environment at night
• Families who require strong room-to-room privacy or lots of storage
• Guests expecting a resort vibe with pool, gym, and lively common areas
• Travelers who want strong local character, design flair, or a home-like apartment feel
How St Augustine Hotel By At Mine Hospitality fits into Miami Beach
Within Miami Beach, this property sits firmly in the South Beach camp: walkable to the sand, Art Deco streets, and nightlife, without the price tag of the big oceanfront names. You are here for proximity, not for a glamorous address or sweeping ocean views.
Compared with the grand resorts in Mid-Beach and the quieter family hotels farther north, this is better used as a city base. You gain easy access to restaurants, bars, and cultural spots, and in return you accept more street energy and less on-site calm.
If you want an iconic, see-and-be-seen hotel, Miami Beach has many. If you care more about a functional, modern room near the core action, this property is relevant.
The location also works well for people who need to move between Miami Beach and the mainland. You are close enough to key causeway routes that airport and downtown trips are manageable compared with staying deep in North Beach, which matters during heavy traffic or major events.
The trade you are making is straightforward: this is the practical, logistics-friendly choice inside the South Beach grid, not the destination hotel you brag about later.
Matching the hotel to your trip purpose
For nightlife-focused trips where you want to walk to bars, clubs, and late restaurants, this hotel lines up well. You avoid nightly rideshares and still come back to a room that feels clean and modern, even if the building is not perfectly insulated from the surrounding activity.
If the beach is your main event and you plan to go multiple times a day, the short walk and ability to pop back for breaks are real strengths. You give up a beachfront pool and cabanas, but you also avoid resort pricing.
Work trips or mixed work-leisure stays can function here, thanks to desks, WiFi, and mainland access. The main risk is noise for calls or early nights, so this only makes sense if you tolerate some background sound or pack headphones.
For family holidays or long, slow stays where you want space, privacy, and on-site amenities, this is a weak fit. You would be systematically happier in a larger resort or an apartment-style property farther from the core.
During major Miami Beach events, this property is logistically attractive because you can walk to many venues and avoid the worst traffic. The flip side is that noise and congestion increase, and the lack of retreat-like amenities becomes more obvious when the city is at full volume.
If your priority during an event is simply to make it to sessions and parties on time, it works. If you also want a sanctuary to decompress away from crowds, you should look north or invest in a more insulated hotel.
What reviews say once you read between the lines
• Guests repeatedly praise the cleanliness of rooms and bathrooms
• Location near the beach and Art Deco South Beach is the most consistent highlight
• Staff interactions are described as friendly, responsive, and helpful
• Many guests comment positively on room size relative to expectations
• Noise from the street, other rooms, and AC units shows up as a recurring negative
• Some guests find bathroom layouts compromise privacy when sharing a room
• Breakfast is a weak point, either limited or not reliably available
• A few guests note minor gaps in in-room supplies, though not systematically
• Families and very noise-sensitive travelers are more likely to feel frustrated
• Overall satisfaction is high for couples and solo travelers who came for location first
Dissatisfaction usually appears when guests assume they are booking a quiet, apartment-like stay in a lively area. The building structure, minimal common areas, and South Beach context push the experience toward a classic small hotel with modern rooms, not a retreat or residence.
When expectations are framed as "a clean, central base" rather than "a full-featured hotel" or "a mini-apartment," review sentiment becomes far more uniformly positive.
Key questions, answered
Is St Augustine Hotel By At Mine Hospitality worth it?
It is worth it if your priorities are a clean, modern room, strong South Beach location, and friendly staff at a price below big beachfront resorts. It is not worth it if you want a quiet, amenity-rich, or highly stylish property, because this is essentially a practical sleep base with limited extras.
Is it noisy at night?
Many guests report noticeable noise at night from the street, other guests, and air conditioning units. Some people are fine with it given the South Beach context, but light sleepers and families should expect disturbance and either bring earplugs or choose a quieter, more residential location.
Are the rooms small?
Rooms are not tiny by South Beach standards and are often described as spacious or comfortably sized. They are still just bedrooms and bathrooms without separate living areas, so they work best for couples or solo travelers, and less well for families who want more separation and storage.
Is parking easy?
Parking is available but not simple. The hotel uses paid off-site parking rather than an on-site garage, so you should expect extra steps and added cost if you are driving. This setup is typical for the area but will feel inconvenient if you planned to use a car frequently during your stay.
Parking is where many first-time Miami Beach visitors underestimate friction. Between causeway traffic, limited street parking, and reliance on paid off-site options, driving here is rarely smooth. This property works best for people who park once and mostly walk, not for those planning to be in and out by car multiple times a day.
On room size, remember that many South Beach buildings are historic and cut into small rooms. Within that landscape, this hotel sits on the comfortable side of average, which explains why guests notice and call out the sense of space despite the minimalist furniture.
Updated:
Jan 14, 2026