Collins Hotel in Miami Beach works if you want a basic beach base with a pool, but skip it if you care about quiet, spotless rooms, or fresh, updated interiors.
Collins Hotel in one look
• Choose Collins Hotel if you want a cheap, convenient base across from the beach and can shrug off rough edges
• Expect simple, dated rooms and understand that cleanliness and maintenance are inconsistent
• Treat the pool and location as the main value; the building itself is closer to a basic motel than a beach resort
• Do not book if you are noise sensitive, highly cleanliness focused, or traveling with kids who need reliable quiet
• Factor in paid parking and lack of breakfast when comparing overall value with other Miami Beach options
The good
• Across the street from the beach on Collins Avenue, with easy access to sand and water
• Outdoor pool and sun deck are genuine features, not token amenities
• Rooms are simple, generally spacious enough, and easy to move around in
• Staff are often described as friendly and helpful at the front desk
• Works as a practical crash pad for short, budget-minded beach trips
The bad
• Recurring reports of noise from the street, other guests, and thin walls
• Cleanliness and maintenance are inconsistent, including pest and wear issues
• Rooms and facilities feel dated compared with many Miami Beach alternatives
• Parking costs extra and irritates many guests who expect it to be cheaper or clearer
• No real breakfast or food service, despite some guests arriving expecting it
Room reality at Collins Hotel
Rooms are straightforward: tiled floors, basic beds with white linens and accent runners, wall mounted TV, a small fridge, and minimal furniture. The photos are accurate in showing uncluttered space and functional layouts rather than style. You get enough circulation around the beds to move bags without tripping over them.
Storage is limited. Expect a small dresser and bedside tables, sometimes a simple desk or table, but not full closets or generous drawers. For a few nights, living out of a suitcase is manageable. For longer stays or families who fully unpack, the lack of real storage will get old.
Work surfaces are an afterthought. Some rooms have a basic desk or table, but it is not a dedicated, ergonomic workstation. Lighting is fine for general use, less so for focused laptop work. If you need a true work setup, this will feel like a compromise.
Décor and finishes are dated and utilitarian. Reviews confirm what the photos suggest: this is not a design hotel, and wear shows in some rooms. There are also consistent complaints about cleanliness misses, maintenance issues like malfunctioning AC or fixtures, and occasional pests, which undercut the otherwise functional layouts.
Noise and environment
Noise is a real factor here and should shape your decision. Multiple reviews mention traffic and street noise from Collins Avenue, as well as sound from other guests and hallways due to thin walls and exterior corridor layouts.
If your primary need is a solid, quiet sleep, this property is risky. Light sleepers, families with young kids, or anyone trying to rest before early flights or work days should treat noise as a potential deal breaker rather than a minor annoyance.
If you are used to city sound, plan to be out late, and are not sensitive to hallway and neighbor noise, you may be fine, but you should not book expecting consistent calm.
Exterior corridors, tiled floors, and basic insulation all amplify sound. Reviews suggest that noise is not confined to a specific wing or time: late night arrivals, voices outside doors, and traffic patterns on Collins all contribute. Guests on shorter leisure trips who are mostly at the beach or out at night report fewer issues, while families and early-to-bed travelers are more likely to complain that the property feels loud and exposed.
Where Collins Hotel holds up and where it does not
What works here
• Location across from the beach and near a golf course is genuinely convenient
• Pool and sun deck are central features and generally well maintained
• Rooms match photos in layout and simplicity, avoiding big bait and switch surprises
• Staff are often praised for being friendly, especially at check in
• Wi‑Fi, fridge, and basic in room amenities support simple, short stays
What does not hold up
• Cleanliness and housekeeping standards fluctuate too much from stay to stay
• Dated décor, worn furniture, and maintenance issues pull down perceived value
• Repeated reports of pests such as cockroaches and ants are a serious concern
• Mechanical reliability, especially AC and elevators, is not guaranteed
• Street and guest noise conflict with the idea of a restful beach escape
The strongest positive anchor is location, not the rooms. Guests forgive a lot when they can cross the street to the beach, but issues like pests, broken AC in Miami heat, and inconsistent housekeeping cut through that goodwill quickly. Complaints cluster around a sense that what is marketed as a simple, comfortable beach hotel often delivers as a tired roadside style property on a great block. Travelers who walk in expecting a budget motel with a pool walk away more satisfied than those who expect a breezy, modern Miami Beach stay.
Amenities and operations in real life
What you can count on
• Outdoor pool and sun deck are real, usable spaces with enough loungers and open deck
• Free Wi‑Fi, flat screen TV, and in room fridge are standard in all rooms
• 24 hour front desk adds basic security and late arrival flexibility
• Vending machines help with simple snacks and drinks
• Proximity to restaurants and cafes nearby fills the on site food gap
Where expectations get people
• Parking costs extra and is a frequent point of frustration on value stays
• No included breakfast, despite some guests arriving assuming there would be one
• Housekeeping can be inconsistent, leaving some rooms feeling less than fully cleaned
• Pool and shared areas are not a social hub; expect low energy rather than a scene
• Facilities feel dated, so anyone expecting resort level amenities will be disappointed
Marketing leans on “sun deck,” pool, and location but has little to say about breakfast, parking, or modern touches like a bar, restaurant, or gym. That silence is accurate: this is a lean operation. Guests who scan photos of the pool and assume a fuller resort setup walk into a property that functions more like a dressed up motel with a good pool and beach access. The paid parking and lack of breakfast compound the sense that advertised value erodes once you arrive.
Who Collins Hotel actually suits
Works for
• Budget conscious beach travelers who value location over room perfection
• Short stay guests using the hotel mainly to sleep, shower, and store bags
• Couples or friends who plan to spend most of their time out around Miami Beach
• Drivers who accept paid parking as part of the total trip cost
• Travelers who are tolerant of dated finishes as long as basics mostly work
Not for
• Light sleepers who need a reliably quiet room at night
• Guests with high cleanliness standards or strong sensitivity to pest risks
• Families seeking a polished, worry free resort or apartment style stay
• Remote workers who need a comfortable, quiet, and well equipped workspace
• Travelers expecting modern design, strong soundproofing, and hotel level polish
How Collins Hotel fits into Miami Beach
Within Miami Beach, Collins Hotel sits in the value segment: close to the beach, basic facilities, and a pool, without the price tag of the more polished oceanfront resorts. Its competitive edge is geography, not experience.
You choose this hotel when you want to be near the water and major corridors without paying for beachfront branding or extensive amenities. Many guests treat it as a launchpad to explore Miami rather than a place to linger.
In the broader city context, there are cleaner, quieter, and more modern options at higher prices, and there are also rougher budget picks further from the beach. Collins Hotel threads the middle: a strong location with compromises in comfort and upkeep that you need to accept to feel it is worthwhile.
Matching Collins Hotel to your trip
For a quick beach weekend where you care more about daytime sun and nightlife than on site comfort, Collins Hotel can work if you go in with modest expectations. The pool, easy beach access, and basic room setup line up with that use case.
For family vacations where you want predictable cleanliness, quiet naps, and a stress free base, the repeated complaints about noise, pests, and maintenance make this a risky bet. You may end up managing problems instead of relaxing.
For work trips or blended work and leisure stays, the lack of a solid desk environment, mixed Wi‑Fi reliability reports, and noise make it a poor choice. You are better off in a more business oriented property even if it is slightly away from the beach.
For value hunters willing to trade polish for price, this can fit if you factor in extra charges like parking and accept that “basic” here really means basic, with real downside variance.
What reviews keep repeating
• Location near the beach is consistently praised and is the main reason people book
• Staff are often described as friendly and accommodating at the front desk
• Many guests like the pool and appreciate having a real place to swim and lounge
• Noise from Collins Avenue, other guests, and thin walls is a recurring complaint
• Cleanliness ratings are split, with both very positive and very negative reports
• Dated rooms, worn furniture, and tired bathrooms reduce perceived value
• Multiple guests report pests in rooms, including cockroaches and ants
• Maintenance problems such as malfunctioning AC or elevators come up often
• Parking costs extra and feels steep or poorly communicated to many travelers
• Some guests feel the total cost does not match what they experienced on site
Dissatisfaction clusters around guests who expected a simple but solid beach hotel and instead experienced multiple small failures at once: noise, a dirty floor, an AC issue, and a parking charge all stacking up. When only one of those problems appears, many guests shrug it off because the location is good. When two or three hit the same stay, the tone of reviews shifts from “basic but fine” to “never again.” The risk is not that every stay is bad, but that variance is high, and you cannot pay your way out of it with room choice.
Collins Hotel high intent questions
Is Collins Hotel worth it?
Collins Hotel is worth it only if your top priority is a low to mid priced stay very close to the beach and you accept real compromises on cleanliness, noise, and dated rooms. Guests who treat it as a place to crash after long days out and who calibrate expectations to “budget motel by the beach with a pool” tend to feel they got fair value. Travelers expecting a clean, modern, consistently maintained hotel are often disappointed and feel the total cost, including parking, is not justified.
Is it noisy at night?
Noise is a common issue. Reviews mention traffic from Collins Avenue, sound from neighboring rooms and hallways, and limited sound insulation due to the building layout and finishes. Some guests are unbothered, especially those out late or used to city environments, but others report difficulty sleeping. If you are noise sensitive or traveling with children, you should consider this property high risk for nighttime disturbance.
Are the rooms small?
Rooms are not especially small for Miami Beach; photos and reviews suggest they are reasonably sized with good circulation space. The problem is not size, but the basic, dated feel and the limited storage and work surfaces. For a few nights, the space works fine for most travelers. For longer stays or families with lots of luggage, the lack of closets and drawers matters more than the square footage itself.
Is parking easy?
Parking is operationally straightforward but not guest friendly on price. Reviews repeatedly note that parking is charged extra and that the cost feels high for a budget oriented hotel. If you are driving, you should plan for this added expense and not expect free or cheap on site parking. Travelers who account for this in advance handle it; those who assume it will be minor or included tend to leave irritated.
Updated:
Jan 15, 2026